What is Buttered Muffin?
1.
a pussy with cum in it
Is your muffin buttered ? would you like me to assign someone to butter your muffin ? - buttered muffin
See
2.
A girl who has had many partners. (Primarily English)
I went out with this girl last Friday, but my friend warned me she was a real buttered muffin, and I decided to quit it.
See
3.
A girl's pussy and anus after somone butters her muffin. This is a sexual act involving oral sex to both holes, and half a stick of butter melted in the vagina used as lubricant for
"Momy! Momy! Can I have a buttered muffin? The man at the store said he'd like to give me one and I REALY like muffins!"
See