What is Catchers Mitt?
1.
an old dry worn out vagina that has seen quite a bit of action.
Johnny lost his boner after seeing Jane's catchers mitt; he wondered who hadn't been between those meat curtains.
See
2.
A dried out, purple pussy usually on an old broad who has not had sex in years. It looks like a vintage catchers mitt from the 1930's.
Beth has a catchers mitt for a snatch....
See
3.
The guy in a fight takes all the punches. A bad fighters that always looses.
spectator: That guy was a real catchers mitt. Did he even get a punch in?
See
4.
1.) Whatever device one uses in order to prevent an ejaculation from reaching nearby surfaces.
"Uh oh, where's my catchers mitt?!"
"Don't worry, I brought mine"
See