What is Chocolate Box?
1.
Anal orifice, esp. that of an attractive female.
After Mike played three consecutive John Mayer CD's, Ashley finally opened up her chocolate box to him.
See
2.
A person (male or female) who is not only good-looking, but charming as well.
Girl #1: Did I tell you that Billy left a surprise in my locker?
Girl #2: No, what was it?
Girl #1: A red rose.
Girl #2: No way! That's so sweet!
Girl #1: I know, he's a real chocolate box.
See