What is Pirate's Eye?
1.
The eye that is damaged or lost from repeated prodding/poking, or
Jake: Hey Zach, what happened to your eye?
Zach: My continued bad ideas led Paul to socket rocketing me repeatedly until my eye fell out. All I have now is this stupid eye patch.
Jake: Dude, that is one nasty Pirate's Eye
See
2.
shitting in a girls eye
i wanted to take a shit but i had to keep fucking her so i gave her the pirate's eye last night.
See