What is Pony Girl?
1.
A bondage chick who likes to wear pony gear like blinders, a bit, and a fake horse tail.
That chick likes it rough, she likes bein' my pony girl.
See
2.
a girl who does beastiality porn or has sexual intercourse with Horses and other animals.
"oh man, we went to Mexico. And we thought it'd be fun to go to a show, and it's a woman fucking a horse. We get there, and we think it's gonna be awesome, and it's not as cool as it sounds like it would be, man. It's kinda gross. You think a woman fucking a horse, and you get there, and it's a woman fucking a horse. It was really giving it to her. And you know what? to be honest I felt bad for her, we all just felt bad for her. Kinda felt bad for the horse." pony girl, lol.
--40 Year Old Virgin
See
3.
Irish slang for a fat girl who think she's sexy.
"Who was that Pony Girl you went home with last night?"
See