What is Red Turtle?
1.
the first shit that you pump out of your ass after a rock hard cock has been in it, causing bleeding such that the tip of the shit is coated in red blood.
she told me to pull out cause she was gonna drop a red turtle in my mouth, but instead she smeared it all over my chest
See
2.
The fecal matter that protrudes out the bum after anal intercours.
"That tasted like a red turtle."
See