What is Soft Cookie?
1.
a game which that involves masturbating in a group (circle jerk) over a cookie. The first person to blast jizz onto the cookie wins. The last person to blow their load eats the cookie, hence, soft cookie.
You lost faggot now eat that damn cookie.
Dude you better stroke harder or you will be eating that soft cookie.
Damn DK, you sure gobbled that soft cookie down.
See