What is Cream Pie Surprise?
1.
when you un-expectedly jizz in a girls asshole, and then it leeks out.
or you whip it out of her ass real quick and unload a full clip in her face and give her a free facial that she was not prepared for
Jill: uhh!...the other day, dave gave me a cream pie surprise!
See
Random Words:
1.
When you bust your load (after doing the deed with a woman) on your ipod nano you grab it by the headphones and slap it across her face ..